Takes about two minutes. Only your first name or chosen display name is shown — your email stays private.
Dr. Matthew Gotlin is a sports medicine physician in Scarsdale, New York, practicing with Stephen J Nicholas MD PC.
Medical school: State University of New York at Stony Brook, School of Medicine, class of 2016.
To book an appointment, call (212) 737-3301. Dr. Gotlin's office is at 2 Overhill Rd Suite 330, Scarsdale, NY 10583. He accepts Medicare assignment — useful to know if you are on traditional Medicare. Telehealth visits are listed as available.
On the hospital side, Dr. Gotlin holds affiliations with Lenox Hill Hospital, NYU Langone Hospitals and White Plains Hospital Center.
Have you been a patient of Dr. Gotlin? A short, fair review — what went well, what didn't — helps the next person choosing a sports medicine physician in Scarsdale.
Dr. Gotlin at a glance
- Specialty
- Sports medicine physician
- Credentials
- MD
- Practice
- Stephen J Nicholas MD PC
- Address
- 2 Overhill Rd Suite 330, Scarsdale, NY 10583
- Phone
- (212) 737-3301
- Medical school
- State University of New York at Stony Brook, School of Medicine (2016)
- Hospital affiliations
- Lenox Hill Hospital, NYU Langone Hospitals, White Plains Hospital Center
- Medicare assignment
- Accepts
- Telehealth
- Available
- NPI number
- 1891141560
- NY license no.
- 304152
Medicare, Medicaid and hospitals
- Medicare patients (2024)
- 234 people with traditional Medicare, average age 76
- Most common services billed to Medicare
- Aspiration and/or injection of fluid from large joint
- X-ray of shoulder, minimum of 2 views
- X-ray of hip, 2-3 views
- Procedures on Medicare Care Compare
- Upper limb (arm) arthroscopy (minimally invasive joint repair) 1–10 procedures
- Lower limb (leg) arthroscopy (minimally invasive joint repair) 1–10 procedures
- Knee replacement 1–10 procedures
- Hip replacement 1–10 procedures
- Medicare quality score (MIPS 2024)
- 81 out of 100 — reported through the group practice
- New York Medicaid
- Enrolled fee-for-service provider since 2022. Medicaid managed-care plans keep their own networks, so check with your plan.
- Hospital pages
- Lenox Hill Hospital · NYU Langone Hospitals · White Plains Hospital Center
Medicare figures cover people with traditional (fee-for-service) Medicare only; services billed for fewer than 11 patients are not published.
Comparing orthopedic surgeons? See 9 in Scarsdale or 149 across Westchester County.
Other orthopedic surgeons in Scarsdale
Dr. Jeffrey Cohen, MDOrthopedic Surgeon · Jeffrey Cohen MD and Mark Kramer MD PCNo reviews yetScarsdale, NY
Dr. Mark Kramer, MDOrthopedic Surgeon · Jeffrey Cohen MD and Mark Kramer MD PCNo reviews yetScarsdale, NY
Dr. Scott Haig, MDOrthopedic Surgeon · White Plains Physician Services PCNo reviews yetScarsdale, NY
Dr. Sergai N. Delamora, MDOrthopedic Surgeon · Stephen J Nicholas MD PCNo reviews yetScarsdale, NY
Dr. Stephen Nicholas, MDOrthopedic Surgeon · Stephen J Nicholas MD PCNo reviews yetScarsdale, NY
Dr. Steven J. Lee, MDOrthopedic Surgeon · Stephen J Nicholas MD PCNo reviews yetScarsdale, NYWrite a review
Frequently Asked Questions
With Stephen J Nicholas MD PC, at 2 Overhill Rd Suite 330, Scarsdale, NY 10583.
Call the office at (212) 737-3301.
Yes — Dr. Gotlin accepts Medicare assignment, taking the Medicare-approved amount as full payment for covered services.
Lenox Hill Hospital, NYU Langone Hospitals and White Plains Hospital Center.
Is this your profile?
